ORCA is concerned with the news that AAK has proposed Rame Likaj as Minister of Education. ORCA considers that this proposal is detrimental to education in Kosovo in general and higher education specifically.

Rame Likaj is involved in the biggest scandal in the University of Prishtina, as one of the professors promoted through plagiarism and academic misconduct, known as the case of the Supermen of the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering (FME).

Rame Likaj was promoted from associate professor to full professor in 2018 through a fraudulent process. Rame Likaj presented 19 scientific papers in his promotions application, in the time period of 1.5 years, 19 times more than his Norwegian peers who publish no more than 1 paper a year.

Together with 7 other professors, Likaj was promoted through papers in fake journals which enabled them to boost the number of papers published through academic misconduct. ORCA conducted a wide investigation of all the papers of the professors and compiled a massive report of 492 pages, which was sent to the Council of Ethics in the University of Prishtina. In this file there’s clear evidence that in the papers of the aforementioned 8 professors (including Rame Likaj), there’s copying without referencing – i.e. plagiarism; spelling and grammar mistakes (poor translation); presenting the same content with two different titles as two different papers.

Furthermore, a year later, in 2019, the indexing platform SCOPUS removed the journals where these papers were published, after ORCA denounced them to SCOPUS. So there’s no doubt that the papers of the candidate for minister were fraudulent and that his promotion was unmerited.

ORCA sees the potential appointment as a direct attack on the quality of education in Kosovo. ORCA will take all the necessary measures to prevent and fight such an attack using all the democratic tools in possession.

—————————————————————

Chronology of the events:

On October 8, 2018, ORCA filed a case in the Council of Ethics in the University of Prishtina against 8 professors of the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, who had been promoted with papers in dubious journals. The 8 professors had published 7 to 19 papers each in the timespan of 1.5 years. This is impossible, if we take into account the fact that a mechanical engineering professor in Norway can only publish 0.96 papers a year, not even a full paper.

The 8 professors were promoted through these papers. Most of the papers contain plagiarism, spelling and grammar mistakes in English, which makes these papers impossible to be published in qualitative journals. Nonetheless, the journals where these papers were published were indexed in the SCOPUS indexing platform.

Parallel to this, ORCA raised its suspicions about the journals to SCOPUS on July 8, 2018.

In the meantime, ORCA conducted a wide investigation on the papers of the denounced professors and compiled a massive report of 492 pages, which was sent to the Council of Ethics. In this file there’s clear evidence that in the papers of these 8 professors, there’s copying without referencing – i.e. plagiarism; spelling and grammar mistakes (poor translation); presenting the same content with two different titles as two different papers.

On April 23, 2019, SCOPUS notified ORCA that the journals are no longer indexed starting from 2019: “the publisher [of the journals] has been notified that the SCOPUS coverage for the two titles will not continue for 2019 and beyond.”

This note from SCOPUS was shared with the Council of Ethics on May 8, 2019.

The SCOPUS decision to remove the two journals from its indexing platform in 2019 is based on the evaluation of their work for 2017 and 2018, when the 8 professors published their papers and were promoted.

So we can say beyond any reasonable doubt that: Ahmet Shala, Ramë Likaj, Azem Kyçyku, Mirlind Bruçi, Naser Lajqi, Nexhat Qehaja, Rexhep Selimaj, Xhevat Berisha, were promoted with papers published in predatory journals.

The Council of Ethics has not reached a final decision for the case, leaving it unfinished.